A fault model for ontology mapping, alignment, and linking systems

Authors: 
Johnson, H.L.; Cohen, K.B.; Hunter, L.
Author: 
Johnson, H
Cohen, K
Hunter, L
Year: 
2007
Venue: 
Pacific Symposium on Biocomputing, 2007
URL: 
http://psb.stanford.edu/psb-online/proceedings/psb07/johnson.pdf
Citations: 
15
Citations range: 
10 - 49
AttachmentSize
Johnson2007Afaultmodelforontology.pdf192.96 KB

There has been much work devoted to the mapping, alignment, and linking of ontologies (MALO), but little has been published about how to evaluate systems that do this. A fault model for conducting ne-grained evaluations of MALO systems is proposed, and its application to the system described in Johnson et al. [15] is illustrated. Two judges categorized errors according to the model, and inter-judge agreement was calculated by error category. Overall inter-judge agreement was 98% after dispute resolution, suggesting that the model is consistently applicable. The results of applying the model to the system described in [15] reveal the reason for a puzzling set of results in that paper, and also suggest a number of avenues and techniques for improving the state of the art in MALO, including the development of biomedical domain specific language processing tools, ltering of high frequency matching results, and word sense disambiguation.